Week 2: Variance Management Systems Issues

Bob Luttman, Robert Luttman & Associates

                                               
Home Page

Overview

Statistical Issues

Multi-collinearity

Cascade Effect

Sample Size

Halo Effect

Operational Issues: Documentation and Reporting

Too Much Data

Traditional Pathway / Variance Documentation

What's Wrong With This Picture?

Operational Issues: Summary

Legal Issues: Overview

Legal Issues

The Biggest Issue: So What?

Summary and Conclusion

Assignment

Feedback

Questions?

Cascade Effect

The cascade effect, one variance triggering a series of variances, is the leading cause of multi-collinearity.

Conversely, as we will discuss in upcoming sessions, the cascade effect is also a powerful process improvement tool. If you can eliminate the cascade trigger you can eliminate a great many variances. This is called leverage. Finding and mitigating these variances is a priority for process improvement efforts.

For variance analysis purposes, though, it greatly complicates your ability to identify causal relationships using traditional statistical tools. To simply correlate each variance with some outcome is invalid, they are not independent. And, without the proceeding diagram or other process knowledge, the correlation matrix will not identify the cascade trigger.

The larger issue here, as with multi-collinearity, is: statistical knowledge without process knowledge is like a Ferrari without wheels. Looks cool but it ain't goin' anywhere!

Again, for the biostatisticans in the crowd, Yes statistical tools and techniques exist that mitigate the problem. But, again, can the average staff person use these tools in the heat of battle?

These more sophisticated tools are also limited by two other issues: sample size and the halo effect.

Home Page | Overview | Statistical Issues | Multi-collinearity | Cascade Effect | Sample Size | Halo Effect | Operational Issues: Documentation and Reporting | Too Much Data | Traditional Pathway / Variance Documentation | What's Wrong With This Picture? | Operational Issues: Summary | Legal Issues: Overview | Legal Issues | The Biggest Issue: So What? | Summary and Conclusion | Assignment | Feedback | Questions?

rluttman@robertluttman.com
Improving Healthcare Across the Continuum